Sign Up for Mailing List   Contact Us   Advertise    Request Reprints of Articles

NJLawman.com
N E W S,  O P I N I O N,  C O M M E N T A R Y
                                          
 

       L A W   E N F O R C E M E N T   M A G A Z I N E


2014 NJ Police Training & Schools

Visit Us on Facebook

Follow Us on Twitter

Visit
Our
2014
NJ
Police Training
&
Schools Section

 

Features

Home

NJ Law Enforcement

Site Search

Editorials

Roll Call

Opinions

Photo of the Week

Links

Site Map

 

News

Police News

News Archives Nation

News Archives NJ

L/O Duty Deaths

Events

 

Marketplace

LE Equipment

LEO Gifts

 

Click here to receive NJ Law Enforcement Bulletins

 

Training

NJ Police Training

National Training

 

Resources

Invest Resources

NJ Media Center

10 Deadly Sins

NJ Newspapers

Comp Time Law

NJ Most Wanted

Police Videos

Entry Level

Links

Police Poems

National Police Week

 

IA

IA Resource Center

Garrity Warning

 

Forums

Forums

 

NJLawman.com

About Us & Info

Advertise

Contact Us

Contact Us

 

Satellite Phones  An Asset
for Disasters

 

Law Enforcement
&
Police
Grants

 

Stinger Flashlights

What you Need to Know  Before Making a Purchase!

 

PBA Loan

 

Police and Law Enforcement Home  >  Police News  >  Court Says Defense Attorneys Don't Have Right to Inspect DWI Rooms

 

NJLawman.com

Police News

Police and
Law Enforcement News


 

 

 

 

Court Says Defense Attorneys Don't Have Right to Inspect DWI Rooms

NJLawman.com
Police and Law Enforcement News
Wednesday, October 24, 2012  10:31 a.m.

 

An interesting case came out of the appellate division Tuesday.

A three-judge panel held that defense attorneys are not entitled to - as part of their defense - inspect the rooms where breath tests are administered. 

The decision actually arose from two cases. 

In New Jersey vs. Michael Carrero, the defense wanted to inspect the room where the breath tests were administered to insure that setup was compliant with the rules regarding electronic equipment being in close proximity to the breath machine.

In New Jersey vs. Baluski, the defense attorney sought to examine the room to make sure that the trooper "continuously observed [the defendant] for twenty minutes before the Alcotest was administered."

The law division agreed with the attorneys in both cases and ruled that the rooms could be inspected and photographed.

The appellate court, however, reversed.  In rendering their decision they consolidated both cases as the issue in each was similar.

The court cited the security concerns of routinely allowing civilians access to secured areas of police departments and holding facilities.

But, they did leave room for such inspections under certain circumstances. 

The court stated:

Consistent with these distinctive principles of relevancy applicable in the DWI context, each defendant before us must demonstrate that the stationhouse inspection that he seeks is reasonable and relevant to a material issue to his prosecution.  For the reasons that follow, we conclude that neither defendant has met that burden, and that the Law Division judge erred in granting their respective discovery requests. We address each case individually.

They went on to discuss how the argument in each case failed to meet the threshold set forth above.

To view the cases in their entirety, use the links below:

New Jersey vs. Carrero  (PDF File)

New Jersey vs. Baluski  (PDF File)

It was not immediately apparent as to whether either of the cases would be pursued to the state supreme court.

-NJLawman.com

 

 

Visit Our 2013 NJ Police Training & Schools Section

Mailing List

Receive New Jersey Law Enforcement bulletins
If you would like to receive New Jersey law enforcement
bulletins and/or law enforcement job announcements, click here.

Police and Law Enforcement Home    Advertise    Submit Your Site
Submit Police News   Police Grants    Police Forums    Police News

Copyright 2002-2014-All Rights Reserved  Law Enforcement Media Group - (Not an Official Police Department)    PERC

 

S O C I A L    M E D I A